Old Dominion Athletic Conference
All-Time Swimming All-Conference Teams
2015
Swimmer of the Year: Bobby Brajdic, Sr., Randolph-Macon
Rookie of the Year: Tommy Thetford, Fr., Washington and Lee
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Lee Ayscue, Sr., Hampden-Sydney
Coach of the Year: Brent Kintzer, Randolph-Macon
All-Conference
| Bobby Brajdic | R-MC | Thomas Caldwell | W&L |
| Ivan Fadeyev | R-MC | John Carmody | W&L |
| Robert Redenz | R-MC | Thomas Ferguson | W&L |
| Mohamed Saleh | R-MC | Billy Fries | W&L |
| Tyler Shand | R-MC | Brennan Haley | W&L |
| Trent Babcock | W&L | Matt Kiser | W&L |
| Jake Burns | W&L | Noah Schammel | W&L |
| Tommy Thetford | W&L |
2016
Swimmer of the Year: Tommy Thetford, Washington and Lee
Rookie of the Year: Sam Childress, Washington and Lee
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Josh Carter, Randolph-Macon
Coach of the Year: Kami Gardner, Washington and Lee
All-Conference
| Ivan Fadeyev | R-MC | Corey Connelly | W&L |
| Robert Redenz | R-MC | Thomas Ferguson | W&L |
| Mohamed Saleh | R-MC | Austin Jennings | W&L |
| Thomas Agostini | W&L | Noah Schammel | W&L |
| Trent Babcock | W&L | Tommy Thetford | W&L |
| Andrew Botelho | W&L | Sam Childress | W&L |
| Thomas Caldwell | W&L |
2017
Swimmer of the Year: Robert Redenz, Sr., Randolph-Macon
Rookie of the Year: Reilly Geise, Fr., Greensboro
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Tommy Thetford, Jr., Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: Betsy Leonard, Hampden-Sydney
All-Conference
| Hudson Elmore | H-SC | Patrick Lawrence | W&L |
| Ivan Fadeyev | R-MC | Sammy Logue | W&L |
| Ealon Mann | R-MC | Jared Nickodem | W&L |
| Robert Redenz | R-MC | Noah Schammel | W&L |
| William Borst | W&L | Michael Struk | W&L |
| Ben Brown | W&L | Tommy Thetford | W&L |
| Ethan Fischer | W&L |
2018
Swimmer of the Meet: Tommy Thetford, Sr., Washington and Lee
Rookie of the Meet: Patrick Sullivan, Fr., Washington and Lee
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Tommy Thetford, Sr., Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: Kami Gardner, Washington and Lee
All-Conference
| Ivan Fadeyev | R-MC | Jared Nickodem | W&L |
| Victor Kontopanos | R-MC | Fitz Rawls | W&L |
| Jordan Witherow | R-MC | Noah Schammel | W&L |
| Ben Brown | W&L | Patrick Sullivan | W&L |
| Thomas Caldwell | W&L | Tommy Thetford | W&L |
| Ethan Fischer | W&L | Jonathan Tucker | W&L |
| Danny Lynch | W&L |
2019
Swimmer of the Meet: Patrick Sullivan, So., Washington and Lee
Rookie of the Meet: Connor Kinkema, Fr., Roanoke
ODAC/Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete of the Year: Danny Lynch, So., Washington and Lee
Coach of the Year: Scott Thacker, Roanoke
Bonnie Kestner Sportsmanship Award: Kelley Hilliker, Sr., Bridgewater
All-Conference
| Woody Parsons | H-SC | Nick McGrath | RC |
| Wyatt Boyer | R-MC | Danny Lynch | W&L |
| Victor Kontopanos | R-MC | Jared Nickodem | W&L |
| Bryan McCarthy | R-MC | Fitz Rawls | W&L |
| Joe Stephens | R-MC | Patrick Sullivan | W&L |
| Parker Devillier | RC | Conner Van Vooren | W&L |
| Connor Kinkema | RC | Steven Warren | W&L |