A year ago, 30 All-ODAC standouts returned to league rosters for the 2023 season. Entering 2024, the story is a bit different with 19 all-league players returning to conference diamonds.
Shenandoah leads the way with 5-of-9 All-ODAC players back, while Lynchburg features four of its seven all-conference stars. Two other schools feature multiple returners – Washington and Lee with 3-of-4 back in Lexington and Guilford with 2-of-4 first team Quakers back in Greensboro.
Of the five special individual award winners, only two will be back in league stadiums. Lynchburg closer Jack Bachmore was the 2023 ODAC Pitcher of the Year, while Shenandoah mentor Kevin Anderson returns to the Hornets dugout after earning ODAC Coach of the Year laurels.
- All-ODAC First Team Returners (5)
- RP: Jack Bachmore, LYN
- 1B: Isaiah Hairston, GC
- SS: Frankie Ritter, SU
- OF: Gavin Horning, SU
- UT: Chase Wade, GC
- All-ODAC Second Team Returners (6)
- SP: Jacob Bell, SU
- RP: Evan Blair, WLU
- 1B: Pearce Bucher, SU
- SS: Jonny Wall, RC
- OF: Matt Myers, RMC
- UT: Bryce Thacker, FC
- All-ODAC Third Team Returners (8)
- SP: John Benner, WLU
- RP: Brian Ferreira, SU
- C: Campbell Charneco, WLU
- 1B: Josh Gjormand, LYN
- 2B: Benton Jones, LYN
- 3B: Nick Arnold, EMU
- SS: Brandon Garcia, LYN
- DH: Brandan Hartman, BC