| Kills (Overall) | 70 - VWU vs. Randolph-Macon (9/13/23)
70 - BC vs. Guilford (10/14/23) | 32 - Grace Parker, RMC vs. Susquehanna (9/9/23) |
| Kills (3 Sets) | 53 - VWU vs. Salem (9/2/23) | 21 - Reagan Stoop, BC vs. William Peace (9/8/23) |
| Kills (4 Sets) | 63 - VWU vs. Salisbury (10/7/23) | 32 - Grace Parker, RMC vs. Susquehanna (9/9/23) |
| Kills (5 Sets) | 70 - VWU vs. Randolph-Macon (9/13/23)
70 - BC vs. Guilford (10/14/23) | 31 - Reagan Stoop, BC vs. Guilford (10/14/23) |
| Assists (Overall) | 68 - BC vs. Guilford (10/14/23) | 51 - Maddi Page, GC vs. Bob Jones (10/7/23) |
| Assists (3 Sets) | 50 - RMC vs. Washington and Lee (10/4/23) | 41 - Ashley Rutherford, WLU vs. Bridgewater (10/18/23) |
| Assists (4 Sets) | 61 - VWU vs. Washington and Lee (10/7/23) | 46 - Kaitlin Kaplan, RMC vs. Muskingum (9/2/23) |
| Assists (5 Sets) | 68 - BC vs. Guilford (10/14/23) | 45 - Maddi Page, GC vs. William Peace (9/9/23) |
| Digs (Overall) | 127 - AU vs. Ferrum (10/4/23) | 47 - Erin Gray, AU vs. Ferrum (10/4/23) |
| Digs (3 Sets) | 94 - BC at Washington and Lee (10/18/23) | 27 - Sophia Stites, BC at Washington and Lee (10/18/23) |
| Digs (4 Sets) | 93 - AU vs. Randolph-Macon (9/29/23) | 34 - Cara Caruso, VWU vs. Washington and Lee (10/7/23) |
| Digs (5 Sets) | 127 - AU vs. Ferrum (10/4/23) | 30 - Cassi Blackmore, LYN vs. Asbury (9/1/23) |
| Aces (Overall) | 20 - HU vs. PSU Abington (10/14/23) | 9 - Aubrey Brown, RC vs. Hollins (10/12/23) |
| Aces (3 Sets) | 19 - RAND vs. Trinity (DC) (9/16/23) | 9 - Aubrey Brown, RC vs. Hollins (10/12/23) |
| Aces (4 Sets) | 20 - HU vs. PSU Abington (10/14/23) | 8 - Jaina Leek, LYN vs. Shenandoah (10/14/23) |
| Aces (5 Sets) | 17 - GC vs. Roanoke (9/13/23) | 6 - McKenna Cook, WLU vs. Marymount (9/9/23)
6 - Emma Nash, AU vs. Ferrum (10/4/23) |
| Blocks (Overall) | 16 - LYN vs Asbury (9/1/23) | 11 - Princess Salifou, LYN vs. Asbury (9/1/23) |
| Blocks (3 Sets) | 11 - RAND vs. Guilford (10/21/23) | 7 - Ryan Taylor, W&L vs. York (Pa.) (9/1/23)
7 - Emery Goerig, W&L vs. PSU-Mont Alto (9/2/23)
7 - Breana Brooks, VWU vs. Marymount (9/16/23)
7 - Brooke Murdock, RAND vs. Hollins (9/30/23) |
| Blocks (4 Sets) | 14 - RAND vs. Averett (9/19/23)
14 - RAND vs. Lynchburg (10/4/23) | 9 - Brooke Murdock, RAND vs. Lynchburg (10/4/23) |
| Blocks (5 Sets) | 16 - LYN vs. Asbury (9/1/23) | 11 - Princess Salifou, LYN vs. Asbury (9/1/23) |