FOREST, Va. --- The ODAC's record-breaking four NCAA Division III Women's Soccer Championship qualifiers account for 27 all-conference team positions to headline the 2025 All-ODAC Women's Soccer Awards.
Batten University and Bridgewater College each lead the way with eight All-ODAC honorees with ODAC champion Washington and Lee University seeing seven generals recognized and the University of Lynchburg securing six all-league assignments.
The sport's special award winners were split among three of those four schools plus one representative from Shenandoah University. WLU mentor Tiffany Pins garnered ODAC Coach of the Year laurels, while Generals' midfielder Megan Zimmerman was tabbed the ODAC/Virginia Farm Bureau Insurance Scholar-Athlete of the Year by the league's athletic communications personnel. Bridgewater forward Laura Narby earned ODAC Player of the Year recognition, while Batten goalkeeper Allie Greco received ODAC Defensive Player of the Year plaudits. Shenandoah forward Ella Cieri collected ODAC Rookie of the Year accolades.
The 2026 All-ODAC awards list features 39 players between the All-ODAC First, Second, and Third Teams. Among those honorees, 15 earned all-conference distinction for at least the second straight season including six members of the first team. Narby is a repeat first teamer, which is also true for WLU twin sisters Megan and forward Elizabeth Zimmerman as well as Shenandoah attacking midfielder McKenna Newcome and Batten fullback Tori Mills. Lynchburg central midfielder Lauren Orner moved up from last year's second team.
The All-ODAC Second Team features five repeat honorees. Bridgewater center midfielder Katherine King was a first team choice last year, while Eagles' teammate and keeper Erinn Lockard and SU winger Lauren Duffy are back-to-back second team selections. Marlins' outside midfielder Kaylyn Seitz and Roanoke College centerback Bree Fulkerson both moved up from the 2025 third team.
This season's All-ODAC Third Team features four stars that are appearing on the awards list for at least a second straight season. Washington and Lee keeper Kate McEnroe was a first team selection last year, while Batten centerback Alex Ortega and Roanoke forward Rebecca Carr were second team honorees. Bridgewater center midfielder Cassie Villafan repeats as a third team choice.
Narby, a senior from Huntington, N.Y., has long been one of the best attackers in the conference, but reached new levels the past two seasons by combining for 37 goals and seven assists towards 61 of her 90 career points. Entering the NCAA Tournament, Narby is tied for third in the ODAC in points (30), third in goals scored (13), and has notched four assists. Five of her goals count as game-winning tallies, which is tied for second in the league. She puts the most pressure on defenses with an ODAC-best 80 shots, seven more than the player positioned second on the ODAC chart.
Greco, a junior from Red Bank, N.J., has been nothing short of stellar this season as she leads the ODAC in all major goalkeeping statistical categories. That includes save percentage (.930), goals against average (0.191), and clean sheets (11). Those figures rank first, second, and tied for second, respectively, in Division III. Batten is tied for the Division III lead in goals allowed with just three, joining Rowan University atop the 411-team chart.
Pins is in the midst of her fifth season on Washington and Lee's sideline and 16th year overall as a collegiate women's soccer head coach. This is her third straight and fourth overall ODAC top-coaching award. The Generals lifted their straight and seventh overall ODAC women's soccer trophy on Saturday. The conference's automatic entry to the Division III Women's Soccer Championship will host a four-team pod during the tournament's first and second round this weekend. WLU is currently 16-1-2 (.895) and ranked fourth in the latest IWSOC/United Soccer Coaches Top-25 Poll. Pins' updated career records stand at 214-63-42 (.737) overall and 81-11-15 (.827) in Lexington.
Cieri, a first-year from Pasadena, Md., was a key cog in Shenandoah's attack, coming off the bench for most of the season before starting three of the Hornets' final five matches. Cieri tied for ninth in the ODAC with eight goals scored and added a pair of assists to rank 13th in the conference with 18 points.
Megan Zimmerman, a junior from Cincinnati, Ohio, stars on and off the field for Washington and Lee as she pairs the ODAC/Virginia Farm Bureau Scholar-Athlete of the Year award with her third straight selection to the All-ODAC First Team. In the classroom, Zimmerman -- the second straight Zimmerman to earn this award along with older sister Sarah Zimmerman in 2025 -- boasts a 3.89 GPA as an accounting and sociology double-major. The four-time W&L Scholar-Athlete and two-time ODAC All-Academic Team honoree has twice been named to W&L's President's List. A private equity analyst over the summer, Zimmerman is the Vice President of Finance for the Delta Society and serves her communities through Morgan's Message and the Rockbridge Youth Literacy Program.
Zimmerman, a two-sport student-athlete (basketball), is a former ODAC Rookie of the Year (2024) the soccer pitch. She currently ranks second in the ODAC in points (31), tied for third in assists (7), and tied for fourth in goals scored (12) with Washington and Lee awaiting play in the NCAA first round this weekend.
2026 ALL-ODAC WOMEN’S AWARDS
ODAC Player of the Year: Laura Narby, Sr., F, Bridgewater
ODAC Defensive Player of the Year: Allie Greco, Jr., GK, Batten
ODAC Coach of the Year: Tiffany Pins, Washington and Lee
ODAC Rookie of the Year: Ella Cieri, Fy., F, Shenandoah
ODAC/Va. Farm Bureau Insurance Scholar-Athlete: Megan Zimmerman, Jr., M, Washington and Lee
| ALL-ODAC FIRST TEAM |
| Alaina Alston |
Sr. |
F |
Batten |
| Laura Narby * |
Sr. |
F |
Bridgewater |
| Makayla Hargrove |
So. |
F |
Lynchburg |
| Elizabeth Zimmerman * |
Jr. |
F |
Washington and Lee |
| Madison Toone |
Jr. |
M |
Batten |
| Lauren Orner ^ |
Sr. |
M |
Lynchburg |
| McKenna Newcome * |
Jr. |
M |
Shenandoah |
| Megan Zimmerman * |
Jr. |
M |
Washington and Lee |
| Tori Mills * |
So. |
D |
Batten |
| Lune DenHartog |
So. |
D |
Lynchburg |
| Elizabeth Perri |
Jr. |
D |
Washington and Lee |
| Alex Van Arsdale |
Fy. |
D |
Washington and Lee |
| Allie Greco |
Jr. |
GK |
Batten |
| |
|
|
|
| ALL-ODAC SECOND TEAM |
| Brianna Curro |
Jr. |
F |
Bridgewater |
| Bridget Hay |
So. |
F |
EMU |
| Ella Cieri |
Fy. |
F |
Shenandoah |
| Emily Burke |
Sr. |
F |
Washington and Lee |
| Kaylyn Seitz + |
Jr. |
M |
Batten |
| Katherine King * |
Sr. |
M |
Bridgewater |
| Lauren Duffy ^ |
Sr. |
M |
Shenandoah |
| Amelia Manke |
Sr. |
M |
Washington and Lee |
| Jocelyn Robinson |
Fy. |
D |
Batten |
| Laney Fayard |
So. |
D |
Bridgewater |
| Maryn Harris |
So. |
D |
Bridgewater |
| Bree Fulkerson + |
Sr. |
D |
Roanoke |
| Erinn Lockard ^ |
So. |
GK |
Bridgewater |
| |
|
|
|
| ALL-ODAC THIRD TEAM |
| Alexis Manfredi |
Jr. |
F |
Batten |
| Leigha Gronau |
Fy. |
F |
Lynchburg |
| Casey Serttas |
So. |
F |
Randolph |
| Rebecca Carr ^ |
Sr. |
F |
Roanoke |
| Sophia Phillips |
Jr. |
M |
Bridgewater |
| Cassie Villafan + |
Jr. |
M |
Bridgewater |
| Ally Hopkins |
Fy. |
M |
Lynchburg |
| Emma Owens |
So. |
M |
Randolph-Macon |
| Alex Ortega ^ |
Jr. |
D |
Batten |
| Lily Kuykendall |
Fy. |
D |
Lynchburg |
| Brodie Russ |
Jr. |
D |
Randolph-Macon |
| Elliana Bauer |
Fy. |
D |
Shenandoah |
| Kate McEnroe * |
Jr. |
GK |
Washington and Lee |
* 2025 All-ODAC First Team (7)
^ 2025 All-ODAC Second Team (5)
+ 2025 All-ODAC Third Team (3)